By Dileep Solanki
Index mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are designed to follow a market index such as the Nifty 50 or Sensex. Their objective is not to select stocks in an attempt to consistently outperform the market. Instead, they aim to replicate the performance of a chosen benchmark as closely as possible.
However, an index fund does not always deliver exactly the same return as its benchmark. Even when a fund follows the same index, its actual performance can be slightly different because of expenses, cash holdings, transaction costs, delays in buying or selling securities and other operational factors.
This difference is important when comparing index funds. Two funds may follow the same benchmark but deliver different results over time. To understand why, investors should know two terms: tracking error and tracking difference.
Although the terms sound similar, they measure different things. Understanding both can help investors evaluate how closely an index fund follows its benchmark.
What Is Tracking Error?
Tracking error measures how consistently a fund's returns differ from the returns of its benchmark over time.
In simple language, it tells you how closely the fund follows the index from one observation period to another. It is generally calculated as the standard deviation of the difference between the fund's daily returns and the benchmark's daily returns over a specified period.
For example, imagine an index fund that follows the Nifty 50. On one trading day, the benchmark rises by 1%, while the fund's NAV rises by 0.95%. On another day, the benchmark falls by 0.5%, while the fund falls by 0.45%.
The fund's return difference is not identical on both days. Tracking error measures how much these differences fluctuate over the selected period.
A lower tracking error generally indicates that the fund's returns have followed the benchmark more consistently. A higher tracking error indicates greater variation in the difference between the fund and its benchmark.
However, tracking error does not tell you the complete amount by which a fund has underperformed over a year. That is where tracking difference becomes useful.
What Is Tracking Difference?
Tracking difference measures the actual return gap between an index fund and its benchmark over a particular period.
Suppose a benchmark delivers an annual return of 12%, while an index fund tracking it delivers 11.6% over the same period. The fund's return is 0.4 percentage points lower than the benchmark.
That 0.4 percentage-point gap is the tracking difference when expressed as the fund's return minus the benchmark's return. Some disclosures may present the benchmark-minus-fund gap instead, so always check the convention used in the report.
Tracking difference helps answer a practical question: how much did the fund's return differ from the index over the period being examined?
For an investor comparing two index funds, this can be particularly useful. A fund may follow its benchmark consistently but still deliver a return that is lower by a noticeable amount over several years.
The Difference Between Tracking Error and Tracking Difference
The easiest way to understand the distinction is to think about consistency versus the size of the return gap.
Tracking error focuses on how much the daily return differences fluctuate. Tracking difference focuses on the cumulative or annualised return gap between the fund and its benchmark over a stated period.
A fund could have relatively low tracking error but still show a negative tracking difference. This can happen when the fund consistently underperforms its benchmark by a small amount.
For example, imagine a fund that trails its benchmark by a similar amount on most trading days. Its daily return differences may be relatively stable, resulting in lower tracking error. But the small shortfall can accumulate over time, creating a negative tracking difference.
Another fund may show a return gap that changes more sharply from day to day. Its tracking error may be higher even if its overall return difference for the selected period is small.
This is why investors should not use one metric as a replacement for the other.
Why Does an Index Fund Not Match Its Benchmark Exactly?
An index fund aims to replicate an index, but operating a real investment portfolio involves costs and practical limitations.
Fund expenses are one important reason. An index fund has an expense ratio that covers the scheme's operating and management expenses. These costs reduce the return available to investors and can contribute to a difference between the fund and its benchmark.
Cash holdings can also affect performance. A fund may keep some money in cash to manage redemptions, expenses or other operational requirements. If the underlying index rises while part of the fund remains uninvested, the fund may not capture the full movement.
Transaction costs arise when the fund buys or sells securities. Brokerage, taxes, market impact and other trading-related expenses can influence the actual return.
Index changes and rebalancing can create additional differences. When an index adds or removes securities or changes their weights, the fund must adjust its portfolio. It may not be possible to complete every trade at exactly the same time or price used in the index calculation.
Market liquidity also matters. Some securities may have limited trading volumes or may become difficult to buy or sell at the desired price. This can affect how closely the fund replicates the benchmark.
These factors explain why tracking differences can occur even when a fund follows its stated investment strategy.
How to Compare Tracking Error Between Index Funds
When comparing two index funds, first make sure they follow the same benchmark. Comparing a Nifty 50 index fund with a Nifty Next 50 fund would not provide a meaningful tracking comparison because the underlying indices are different.
Next, check the tracking error over comparable periods. A lower figure may indicate more consistent benchmark replication, but investors should not make a decision based on a single observation. Look at the period covered by the data and whether the measurement method is comparable.
Also check the tracking difference over longer periods where information is available. A fund with a consistently smaller return gap may have delivered a closer overall result relative to its benchmark.
The Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) provides tracking error and tracking difference information for mutual fund schemes. Investors can use this information along with the latest scheme factsheet and disclosures published by the asset management company.
Why Expense Ratio Is Not the Only Factor to Check
Many investors assume that the index fund with the lowest expense ratio must be the best choice. Lower expenses can be beneficial, but the expense ratio alone does not explain the fund's actual tracking performance.
Imagine two funds following the same index. Fund A has a lower expense ratio, while Fund B has a slightly higher expense ratio. If Fund B manages its cash balance, trading and portfolio adjustments more efficiently, its actual return gap may still be competitive.
This does not mean investors should ignore expenses. It means that expense ratio, tracking error and tracking difference should be considered together.
Investors should also review the scheme's assets under management, fund history, benchmark, investment structure and other relevant disclosures. A newer fund may have limited historical information, so its short-term tracking figures may not provide enough evidence about its performance across different market conditions.
How to Read Tracking Information in a Fund Factsheet
A mutual fund factsheet is one of the useful documents for understanding how a scheme operates. For an index fund, check the benchmark name and confirm that it matches the index you intend to track.
Look for the tracking error figure and the period over which it has been calculated. Then check the tracking difference for the available reporting periods. Do not compare figures from different dates or periods as if they were directly equivalent.
You should also review the expense ratio and the portfolio composition. The factsheet can help you understand whether the fund holds securities in a way that is consistent with its stated benchmark.
If information is unclear, refer to the asset management company's official scheme documents and disclosures. AMFI also provides a dedicated section for tracking error and tracking difference data.
Is Lower Tracking Error Always Better?
A lower tracking error is generally desirable for an index fund because the fund's purpose is to follow its benchmark rather than take active positions away from it.
However, it should not be treated as a guarantee of better investment results. Tracking error measures consistency of return differences, not the absolute return earned by the investor.
A fund can have low tracking error and still underperform its benchmark over time. Similarly, a fund's past tracking figures do not guarantee that it will maintain the same level of tracking in the future.
The benchmark itself may also experience losses. A fund that tracks an index very closely will generally reflect the index's decline as well as its rise, subject to the fund's structure and costs.
A Practical Way to Evaluate an Index Fund
When comparing index funds that follow the same benchmark, start by checking whether their tracking information covers comparable periods. Review tracking difference to understand the actual return gap and tracking error to understand how consistently the fund followed its benchmark.
Then examine the expense ratio, portfolio holdings, fund size, scheme history and the quality of the fund's disclosures. Consider whether the fund is an index mutual fund or an ETF, because the way investors buy and sell these products can differ.
For ETFs, market price and NAV can also differ during trading. Investors may need to consider liquidity and the difference between the market price and the underlying NAV when evaluating the cost of buying or selling ETF units.
There is no single metric that can identify the best fund in every situation. The purpose of these measures is to give investors a clearer picture of how a passive fund behaves relative to its benchmark.
Common Mistakes Investors Should Avoid
One mistake is treating tracking error and tracking difference as identical. They answer different questions, so both should be understood separately.
Another mistake is comparing funds that follow different indices. A fund tracking the Nifty 50 should not be evaluated against the tracking figures of a fund tracking the Nifty Midcap 150 as if they were competing to replicate the same benchmark.
Investors should also avoid relying on a single month's data. Short-term figures can change and may not represent the fund's longer-term tracking behaviour.
Finally, do not assume that a low tracking error means the fund cannot lose money. Tracking quality and investment risk are different concepts. If the underlying index falls, an index fund designed to replicate it is also exposed to that decline.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is tracking error the same as tracking difference?
No. Tracking error measures the variation in the difference between the fund's returns and benchmark returns. Tracking difference measures the actual return gap over a specified period.
What is a good tracking error for an index fund?
A lower tracking error generally indicates more consistent benchmark replication. However, investors should examine the calculation period, the benchmark and the fund's other disclosures rather than relying on a single number.
Can an index fund have low tracking error but negative returns?
Yes. Tracking error measures how closely a fund follows its benchmark, not whether the benchmark itself generates positive returns. If the underlying index declines, the fund may also deliver a negative return while tracking it closely.
Where can I check tracking error and tracking difference in India?
Investors can check the asset management company's official scheme factsheet and disclosures. AMFI also provides a tracking error and tracking difference section on its website.
Does a lower expense ratio guarantee a lower tracking difference?
No. Expenses are one factor that can affect tracking difference, but cash holdings, transaction costs, portfolio adjustments and other operational factors can also influence the final result.
Final Thoughts
Tracking error and tracking difference are useful measures for understanding the performance of index funds and ETFs. Tracking error explains how consistently a fund follows its benchmark, while tracking difference shows the actual return gap over a specified period.
Investors comparing funds that follow the same index should examine both measures along with expenses, portfolio information, liquidity where relevant and scheme disclosures. Looking at these factors together provides a more complete understanding of how a passive fund is operating.
The objective is not to find a fund that guarantees market returns. It is to understand how closely the fund has followed its stated benchmark and what factors may have influenced the difference.
Research and References
- SEBI Investor — Understanding Tracking Error
- SEBI Investor — Index Mutual Funds
- AMFI — Tracking Error and Tracking Difference
- SEBI — Frequently Asked Questions for Mutual Fund Investors
This article is for educational purposes only. Tracking figures are based on historical data and do not guarantee future performance. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing.

0 Comments